Systematic Review & Bibliometric Analysis

Data Extraction Form and Risk-of-Bias Assessment

Designs an extraction form suited to your study type, suggests the appropriate risk of bias tool, and applies both to a study whose text you provide, quoting the evidence.

Expert File analysis prompt Multi-step prompt Not rated yet

Purpose of the prompt

The prompt combines the two most important stages after screening: standardised data extraction, and assessing study quality or risk of bias with a recognised tool, linking each judgement to text from the study.

When to use it?

After full-text screening is finished, and when piloting the extraction form on two or three studies.

Full prompt text

Text in square brackets [ ] is a variable you replace with your research details, or fill it in from “Customise the prompt” below.

You are an expert in systematic reviews and study quality assessment in [Specific field].

Type of included studies: [Type of studies]
Outcomes I need for the synthesis: [Required outcomes]

Part one: design a data extraction form with grouped fields: (study information, participants or data, intervention or model, comparator, outcomes and how they were measured, numerical results needed for pooling, funding and conflicts of interest). Specify the type and allowed values of each field.

Part two: suggest the most suitable risk of bias tool for the type of studies, with justification, and list its domains.

Part three (if I provide the text of a study):
<study>
[Text of a study to test on]
</study>
- Fill in the form from the text only, and write "not reported" for anything missing.
- Apply the tool's domains: the judgement (low/high/some concerns or unclear) with a quote as evidence.

Academic integrity rules (mandatory):
- Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed].
- Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you.
- Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions.
- If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it.
- The risk of bias judgements here are a draft; they must be made by two independent reviewers.

Write the answer in [Answer language].

Customise the prompt

Fill in only what suits you. The line of an empty optional field is removed from the final text, and empty required fields stay in brackets for you to complete later.

Optional; to test the form on a real study.

Preview of the customised prompt

You are an expert in systematic reviews and study quality assessment in [Specific field].

Type of included studies: [Type of studies]
Outcomes I need for the synthesis: [Required outcomes]

Part one: design a data extraction form with grouped fields: (study information, participants or data, intervention or model, comparator, outcomes and how they were measured, numerical results needed for pooling, funding and conflicts of interest). Specify the type and allowed values of each field.

Part two: suggest the most suitable risk of bias tool for the type of studies, with justification, and list its domains.

Part three (if I provide the text of a study):
<study>
[Text of a study to test on]
</study>
- Fill in the form from the text only, and write "not reported" for anything missing.
- Apply the tool's domains: the judgement (low/high/some concerns or unclear) with a quote as evidence.

Academic integrity rules (mandatory):
- Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed].
- Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you.
- Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions.
- If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it.
- The risk of bias judgements here are a draft; they must be made by two independent reviewers.

Write the answer in [Answer language].

Variables you can customise

[Specific field]
Required
[Type of studies]
Optional, choose from: Randomised controlled trials, Observational studies, Diagnostic accuracy studies, Prediction model or machine learning studies, Qualitative studies, Mixed, default value: Randomised controlled trials
[Required outcomes]
Optional
[Text of a study to test on]
Optional
[Answer language]
Optional, choose from: Arabic, English, Arabic with English terms in parentheses, default value: Arabic with English terms in parentheses

Usage example

Example input

Type of studies: diagnostic accuracy studies. Outcomes: sensitivity and specificity. With the text of one study.

Expected output

An extraction form with defined fields, a justified risk of bias tool, and a completed form for one study with judgements supported by quotes.

How to use it

  • Test the form on 2 to 3 studies and adjust the fields before adopting it.
  • Move the form into Covidence or a shared spreadsheet.

Tips for better results

  • For machine learning studies, ask for a specific check for data leakage and external validation.

Limitations and warnings

  • Models can make mistakes when copying exact figures; double human extraction is essential.

Suggested tools for using this prompt

Tools from the directory of research and academic publishing tools that are actually linked to this prompt's task, with the reason each tool is suggested.

Covidence

Tool: Primary Paid with a free trial

A web platform for running systematic reviews: importing studies, dual screening, data extraction and quality assessment.

Research function: Managing every step of a systematic review, from import to the PRISMA diagram.

Why it is suggested: Supports extraction forms and quality assessment with independent reviewers.

Elicit

Tool: Supporting Free with usage limits

An AI research assistant that searches scientific papers semantically, extracts data from them and produces research reports with sources.

Research function: Semantic search of scientific papers, summarising them and extracting information into organised tables.

Why it is suggested: For a first extraction of specific fields from papers, followed by human checking.

SciSpace

Tool: Optional

An AI research platform: literature reviews across more than 280 million papers, chat with PDF files and a writing assistant.

Research function: Searching the literature, explaining papers, extracting data from them and helping with writing, with the sources cited.

Why it is suggested: To read the methods sections and ask clarifying questions about them.

In research workflows

Ratings

Not rated yet
Rate this prompt

One rating per visitor per prompt; submitting again updates your earlier rating. Comments appear after review.

Similar prompts