Academic Paper Writing & Publishing

Choosing a Journal and Avoiding Predatory Venues

Sets criteria for choosing a journal for your research, assesses a list of journals suggested by matching tools, and applies a checklist for spotting predatory journals.

Intermediate Specialised prompt Not rated yet

Purpose of the prompt

Language models do not know the current status of journals, so this prompt does not ask them to name journals. Instead it helps you assess the journals you find with official matching tools against clear criteria.

When to use it?

When the paper is nearly complete and before formatting it for a specific journal.

Full prompt text

Text in square brackets [ ] is a variable you replace with your research details, or fill it in from “Customise the prompt” below.

You are an academic publishing advisor in [Specific field].

Abstract of my paper:
[Paper abstract]

My priorities: [Your priorities]

The candidate journals I found with matching tools, with what I know about them:
[Candidate journals]

Required:
1. Weighted criteria for choosing a journal for this paper (scope, audience, indexing, review time, publication fees, open access policy, acceptance rate if published).
2. Assess each candidate journal against the criteria, based only on what I provided, and list what I must check on its official website.
3. A checklist for spotting predatory journals (email invitations, promises of very fast review, claimed indexing, an editorial board that cannot be verified...).
4. A suggested submission order (plan A, B, C) with justification.

Academic integrity rules (mandatory):
- Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed].
- Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you.
- Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions.
- If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it.
- Do not state an impact factor, quartile or review time for any journal from your memory; ask me to check them.

Write the answer in [Answer language].

Customise the prompt

Fill in only what suits you. The line of an empty optional field is removed from the final text, and empty required fields stay in brackets for you to complete later.

Preview of the customised prompt

You are an academic publishing advisor in [Specific field].

Abstract of my paper:
[Paper abstract]

My priorities: [Your priorities]

The candidate journals I found with matching tools, with what I know about them:
[Candidate journals]

Required:
1. Weighted criteria for choosing a journal for this paper (scope, audience, indexing, review time, publication fees, open access policy, acceptance rate if published).
2. Assess each candidate journal against the criteria, based only on what I provided, and list what I must check on its official website.
3. A checklist for spotting predatory journals (email invitations, promises of very fast review, claimed indexing, an editorial board that cannot be verified...).
4. A suggested submission order (plan A, B, C) with justification.

Academic integrity rules (mandatory):
- Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed].
- Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you.
- Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions.
- If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it.
- Do not state an impact factor, quartile or review time for any journal from your memory; ask me to check them.

Write the answer in [Answer language].

Variables you can customise

[Specific field]
Required
[Paper abstract]
Required
[Your priorities]
Optional
[Candidate journals]
Optional
[Answer language]
Optional, choose from: Arabic, English, Arabic with English terms in parentheses, default value: Arabic with English terms in parentheses

Usage example

Example input

Abstract of a paper on early detection of Alzheimer's from MRI images. Priorities: Q1 or Q2, open access. Five candidate journals.

Expected output

Weighted criteria, an assessment of the candidate journals with points to check, a predatory journal checklist and a submission plan.

How to use it

  • Start with the official matching tools to collect candidates, then run the prompt.
  • Check the indexing directly in Scopus.

Tips for better results

  • Look through recent issues of the journal to see whether it publishes work similar to yours.

Limitations and warnings

  • Information about journals changes; the reliable source is the journal's website and the indexing databases.

Suggested tools for using this prompt

Tools from the directory of research and academic publishing tools that are actually linked to this prompt's task, with the reason each tool is suggested.

An international initiative offering a checklist and practical resources that help researchers choose trusted journals and publishers.

Research function: A list of questions for assessing a journal or publisher before submitting your paper.

Why it is suggested: A well-known checklist for assessing a journal's trustworthiness before submission.

JANE

Tool: Primary

A tool that compares your paper's title or abstract with millions of documents in PubMed to suggest the closest journals, authors and articles.

Research function: Suggesting journals, potential reviewers and similar articles based on PubMed content.

Why it is suggested: Suggests journals and similar authors based on the paper's title and abstract.

A Springer Nature tool that suggests suitable Springer and BMC journals for your paper based on the manuscript details.

Research function: Matching your paper's title and abstract against the publisher's journals and suggesting suitable ones.

Why it is suggested: Matches your manuscript with suitable Springer Nature journals.

A Wiley tool (Beta) that finds the Wiley journals matching your paper's title and abstract.

Research function: Matching your paper's title and abstract against Wiley journals and comparing them.

Why it is suggested: Matches your manuscript with Wiley journals.

Scopus

Tool: Supporting Institutional subscription

An abstract and citation database from Elsevier whose content is curated by independent experts.

Research function: Searching the indexed literature and analysing citations and author and journal metrics.

Why it is suggested: To check the journal's indexing and indicators.

In research workflows

Ratings

Not rated yet
Rate this prompt

One rating per visitor per prompt; submitting again updates your earlier rating. Comments appear after review.

Similar prompts