Purpose of the prompt
The list of contributions is the first thing a reviewer and editor read. The prompt helps you phrase it accurately: each contribution specific, tied to evidence in the paper, and free of hype.
When to use it?
Before writing the introduction and abstract, and when answering a reviewer who says "the contribution is unclear".
Full prompt text
Text in square brackets [ ] is a variable you replace with your research details, or fill it in from “Customise the prompt” below.
You are an editor of a peer-reviewed journal in [Specific field] and an experienced reviewer. Description of my work: [Description of your work] The closest previous work and how my work differs from it (as far as I know): [Closest previous work] Main results: [Main results] Required: 1. Analyse: what is genuinely new (method, data, application, evaluation, theory)? And what is not new? 2. Write 3 to 4 contribution points, each: a specific verb + what it is + the evidence for it in the paper (section or table). 3. Assess each point: is it supported by the stated results? Where is the exaggeration? 4. A paragraph version of the contributions for the end of the introduction. 5. One sentence that sums up the contribution (for the abstract and the cover letter). 6. Questions a reviewer might ask to challenge the originality, and how I should prepare for them. Academic integrity rules (mandatory): - Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed]. - Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you. - Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions. - If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it. - Avoid words such as "for the first time" and "unprecedented" unless I provide evidence for them. Write the answer in [Answer language].You are an editor of a peer-reviewed journal in [Specific field] and an experienced reviewer. Description of my work: [Description of your work] The closest previous work and how my work differs from it (as far as I know): [Closest previous work] Main results: [Main results] Required: 1. Analyse: what is genuinely new (method, data, application, evaluation, theory)? And what is not new? 2. Write 3 to 4 contribution points, each: a specific verb + what it is + the evidence for it in the paper (section or table). 3. Assess each point: is it supported by the stated results? Where is the exaggeration? 4. A paragraph version of the contributions for the end of the introduction. 5. One sentence that sums up the contribution (for the abstract and the cover letter). 6. Questions a reviewer might ask to challenge the originality, and how I should prepare for them. Academic integrity rules (mandatory): - Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed]. - Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you. - Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions. - If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it. - Avoid words such as "for the first time" and "unprecedented" unless I provide evidence for them. Write the answer in [Answer language]. You are an editor of a peer-reviewed journal in {{field}} and an experienced reviewer. Description of my work: {{work}} The closest previous work and how my work differs from it (as far as I know): {{prior}} Main results: {{results}} Required: 1. Analyse: what is genuinely new (method, data, application, evaluation, theory)? And what is not new? 2. Write 3 to 4 contribution points, each: a specific verb + what it is + the evidence for it in the paper (section or table). 3. Assess each point: is it supported by the stated results? Where is the exaggeration? 4. A paragraph version of the contributions for the end of the introduction. 5. One sentence that sums up the contribution (for the abstract and the cover letter). 6. Questions a reviewer might ask to challenge the originality, and how I should prepare for them. Academic integrity rules (mandatory): - Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed]. - Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you. - Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions. - If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it. - Avoid words such as "for the first time" and "unprecedented" unless I provide evidence for them. Write the answer in {{lang}}.
Customise the prompt
Fill in only what suits you. The line of an empty optional field is removed from the final text, and empty required fields stay in brackets for you to complete later.
Preview of the customised prompt
You are an editor of a peer-reviewed journal in [Specific field] and an experienced reviewer. Description of my work: [Description of your work] The closest previous work and how my work differs from it (as far as I know): [Closest previous work] Main results: [Main results] Required: 1. Analyse: what is genuinely new (method, data, application, evaluation, theory)? And what is not new? 2. Write 3 to 4 contribution points, each: a specific verb + what it is + the evidence for it in the paper (section or table). 3. Assess each point: is it supported by the stated results? Where is the exaggeration? 4. A paragraph version of the contributions for the end of the introduction. 5. One sentence that sums up the contribution (for the abstract and the cover letter). 6. Questions a reviewer might ask to challenge the originality, and how I should prepare for them. Academic integrity rules (mandatory): - Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed]. - Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you. - Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions. - If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it. - Avoid words such as "for the first time" and "unprecedented" unless I provide evidence for them. Write the answer in [Answer language].
Variables you can customise
- [Specific field]
- Required
- [Description of your work]
- Required
- [Closest previous work]
- Required
- [Main results]
- Required
- [Answer language]
- Optional, choose from: Arabic, English, Arabic with English terms in parentheses, default value: English
Usage example
Example input
Expected output
How to use it
- Use it before writing the introduction, the abstract and the cover letter.
Tips for better results
- Ask a colleague: can they restate your contribution in one sentence after reading the points?
Limitations and warnings
- The originality assessment depends on how accurately you describe the previous work.
Suggested tools for using this prompt
Tools from the directory of research and academic publishing tools that are actually linked to this prompt's task, with the reason each tool is suggested.
A free, AI-powered academic search engine from the Allen Institute for AI that indexes more than 200 million papers.
Research function: Searching for and discovering scientific papers, with automatic summaries and highlights that help you grasp a paper quickly.
Why it is suggested: To check the closest previous work before claiming originality.
A general AI assistant from OpenAI used for brainstorming, drafting and summarising.
Research function: General text chat that helps you generate and organise ideas and improve your wording.
Why it is suggested: A general language model where you can paste the prompt directly and continue the conversation to improve the result.
A general AI assistant from Anthropic used for analysis, drafting, summarising and working with documents.
Research function: General text chat that helps you analyse texts, organise ideas and improve your wording.
Why it is suggested: A general language model where you can paste the prompt directly and continue the conversation to improve the result.
A platform showing «Smart Citations» that reveal whether later studies support or contradict a scientific claim.
Research function: Assessing scientific evidence through the citation context: supporting, contrasting or just mentioning.
Why it is suggested: To see how competing work has been cited.
In research workflows
Similar prompts
Writing a Paper Introduction (CARS Model)
Builds an introduction with the "Create a Research Space" (CARS) model: establishing the territory, identifying the niche, then occupying it with your work, relying only on your references.
Writing a Journal Paper Abstract
Writes a structured or unstructured abstract according to the journal's requirements, from your own figures and results only, with three versions to compare.
Writing a Cover Letter to the Editor
Writes a concise, persuasive cover letter that links your contribution to the journal's scope and includes the usual declarations without exaggeration.
كتابة قسم المواد والطرائق
نظم البيانات والأجهزة والإجراءات والإعدادات والتحليل بما يسمح بالتكرار.
