Literature Review

Structured Critical Summary of a Paper

Summarises a paper whose text you provide into a structured card: problem, method, data, results, limitations, strengths and weaknesses, keeping the authors' claims separate from the model's assessment.

Intermediate File analysis prompt Not rated yet

Purpose of the prompt

This is not a superficial summary. The prompt reads the text you provide and produces a critical reading card ready to add to your literature matrix, with quotes supporting each point to make checking easier.

When to use it?

When reading an important paper for your topic and you want a standard card for it, or when preparing for a journal club.

Full prompt text

Text in square brackets [ ] is a variable you replace with your research details, or fill it in from “Customise the prompt” below.

You are an expert reviewer in [Specific field].

I will give you the text of a research paper (or its main parts) inside the <paper> tag.

<paper>
[Paper text]
</paper>

My purpose in reading it: [Your purpose in reading]

Create a critical reading card with the following sections:
1. Bibliographic details exactly as they appear in the text (leave anything missing blank).
2. The problem and the research question.
3. Method and design, and the data or sample (size, source, characteristics).
4. Main results with the figures exactly as reported.
5. Limitations stated by the authors.
6. Your critical assessment (separate and clearly headed): internal and external validity, possible data leakage or bias, suitability of the evaluation metrics, and reproducibility.
7. The paper's relevance to my purpose, and what it can be cited for.
8. Three open questions the paper raises.
For every point in sections 2 to 5, add a short quote from the text in quotation marks.

Academic integrity rules (mandatory):
- Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed].
- Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you.
- Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions.
- If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it.

Write the answer in [Answer language].

Customise the prompt

Fill in only what suits you. The line of an empty optional field is removed from the final text, and empty required fields stay in brackets for you to complete later.

Preview of the customised prompt

You are an expert reviewer in [Specific field].

I will give you the text of a research paper (or its main parts) inside the <paper> tag.

<paper>
[Paper text]
</paper>

My purpose in reading it: [Your purpose in reading]

Create a critical reading card with the following sections:
1. Bibliographic details exactly as they appear in the text (leave anything missing blank).
2. The problem and the research question.
3. Method and design, and the data or sample (size, source, characteristics).
4. Main results with the figures exactly as reported.
5. Limitations stated by the authors.
6. Your critical assessment (separate and clearly headed): internal and external validity, possible data leakage or bias, suitability of the evaluation metrics, and reproducibility.
7. The paper's relevance to my purpose, and what it can be cited for.
8. Three open questions the paper raises.
For every point in sections 2 to 5, add a short quote from the text in quotation marks.

Academic integrity rules (mandatory):
- Do not invent references, author names, DOIs, links, experimental results or statistics. Where a source is needed, write [source needed].
- Do not claim to have read a study or file whose text I have not given you.
- Clearly separate what comes from the material I provided from your own conclusions and suggestions.
- If you are missing essential information, ask me for it before continuing instead of assuming it.

Write the answer in [Answer language].

Variables you can customise

[Specific field]
Required
[Paper text]
Required
[Your purpose in reading]
Optional, default value: to decide how relevant the paper is to my research and whether I can cite it
[Answer language]
Optional, choose from: Arabic, English, Arabic with English terms in parentheses, default value: Arabic with English terms in parentheses

Usage example

Example input

Text of a paper on chest X-ray classification with a ViT model, including the method and results sections.

Expected output

An eight-section reading card with supporting quotes and a separate critical assessment.

How to use it

  • If the paper is long, paste only the main sections or use a model that accepts files.
  • Copy the card into your literature matrix or into Zotero notes.

Tips for better results

  • For AI papers, ask for special attention to data splitting and leakage.

Limitations and warnings

  • If you paste only part of the paper, the model may miss important details.
  • Do not rely on the card instead of reading the original paper at the decisive points.

Suggested tools for using this prompt

Tools from the directory of research and academic publishing tools that are actually linked to this prompt's task, with the reason each tool is suggested.

SciSpace

Tool: Primary

An AI research platform: literature reviews across more than 280 million papers, chat with PDF files and a writing assistant.

Research function: Searching the literature, explaining papers, extracting data from them and helping with writing, with the sources cited.

Why it is suggested: To read the paper and ask clarifying questions about its sections.

ChatPDF

Tool: Supporting Free with usage limits

A web tool for chatting with PDF files, summarising and analysing them, pointing to where each answer is in the file.

Research function: Asking questions of a PDF file and getting answers linked to their location in the file.

Why it is suggested: To upload a PDF and chat with it when pasting the text is difficult.

Scholarcy

Tool: Supporting Free with usage limits

A tool that summarises scientific papers into clear summaries, highlights the key statements and links them to the referenced reading.

Research function: Turning a paper into a structured summary, review flashcards and a literature matrix.

Why it is suggested: To extract a first summary card to compare with the prompt's result.

Zotero

Tool: Optional Free

Free, open-source software for collecting, organising, citing and sharing your research sources.

Research function: Saving references from the browser, organising them, and inserting citations and bibliographies in writing software.

Why it is suggested: To save the card as a note attached to the reference.

In research workflows

Ratings

Not rated yet
Rate this prompt

One rating per visitor per prompt; submitting again updates your earlier rating. Comments appear after review.

Similar prompts